

In the first part, Joseph got a job as a Recruit in the Military career and Justine got a job in the Daycare profession because it came with the Generations expansion pack. On Justine’s first day she cared for Joshua Gilbert and Tabbi Claremont. Her work day was quite nightmarish but Joseph helped her out with the kids after he returned from work. Joseph and Justine got engaged in Part 2, when Joseph took her to the park to propose under the stars. In Part 3, Justine meets her best friend Zahra Diwan at the Summer Festival. Justine threw a bachelorette party at The Grind, which was attended by Justine’s friends: Zahra Diwan, Angela and Lilith Pleasant, Cassandra Goth and others. The party was videoed by Joseph.

The wedding had to be postponed a day due to the bad weather conditions, but, ultimately, Joseph and Justine had a quaint wedding attended by all their friends on the pier. Joseph and Justine paddled home in their boat by sunset. The newlyweds tried for a baby once they reached their house. Their first child Luna Fenderson was born and received an Imaginary Friend doll named Snuggles. In Part 9, the family of three moved into the classic Fenderson home. Once a child, Luna frequently set pranks and booby traps around the house, and joined her school's Ballet club, showcasing the mischeif and extracurricular aspects of the expansion. The family also adopted a dog named Buster. The Fendersons’ only son, Jai, was born in Part 15. In Part 16, Luna aged up into a teenager and Penelope became a child. Penelope was sent to the LeFromage Art School in France. In Part 17, Luna met Dedrick Hudson, and wrote a love letter to him. Luna attended Prom alone in Part 19, and despite her winning Prom Queen, the night was a disaster, as she was rejected by her crush (Dedrick) and had a drink thrown in her face. Lifesimmer placed " The New Kids on the Block" in town for Luna to socialize with: Tori Dunbar (The Regina George), Braden (The Jock), Janice West (The Badarse), and DC (The Snob). When the adults went on a free vacation, Luna threw a teen party which they all attended, including Dedrick. During the party, Luna tried to make a move on Dedrick but got rejected. Buster and Tiff’s puppy, Charlie, was also born on that night. When Luna caught Tori dancing with Dedrick, she confronted her, and this lead to their classic rivalry. Luna fought Tori in the girls’ bathroom a the Civic Centre Festival Grounds, and got put in time out by Justine right then and there.

Justine grounded her when she tried to fight Tori again. Penelope comes back to Lucky Palms in Part 23 with an array of new skills from art school. She gets caught pranking Brittlebush Academy when she tries releasing the frogs from the science lab.

